Where to Sell Sports Cards: eBay, Auction, Consignment, PSA, or a Dealer

Where to sell depends on what you have and what each route leaves you after fees, waiting, and risk. For a single card that sells every week, eBay, or PSA's own programs for a slab already at PSA, will usually leave the most if you have the time to list it, and a direct buyer's fixed offer is the number to compare it against. A true trophy card can justify a major auction. Groups of premium cards, stacks of slabs, and whole collections are where a direct buyer can make the most sense: one fixed offer from a card show dealer, a local shop, or a mail-in buyer like us, instead of weeks of listings.

That holds for baseball, football, and basketball cards alike. Below is how to sell sports cards for the most you will actually keep: the fees as each company published them in September 2026, the waits and risks that never show up in a fee table, and three worked examples.

We are a family business that buys cards and sells them, on eBay and on our own site. Where another route will net you more than selling to us, we will say so.

First, sort what you have

Before you choose a route, split your cards into three piles. It takes an afternoon, and it tells you which route fits each pile.

• The few that matter. Graded slabs of stars and key rookies, raw rookies of stars, autographs, numbered cards, and vintage Hall of Famers. In most collections this small pile holds most of the money.
• The middle. Cards worth a few dollars to a few dozen each: good players, inserts, parallels, and complete sets.
• The rest. Base cards and commons, which sell by the box.

While you sort, sleeve and top-load anything valuable, and never clean, trim, or "fix" a card; an altered card loses its value and its buyers' trust. Not sure which pile a card belongs in? Our guide to finding what a card is worth shows how to check real sales.

Baseball, football, or basketball: does it matter?

Less than the era does. Cards from before about 1980, especially Hall of Famers and rookies, have serious specialist buyers even in lower grades, and the best of them belong in a slab, at auction, or with a dealer who knows vintage. Cards from the late 1980s and early 1990s were printed in such huge numbers that, outside a short list of stars and famous errors, they sell by the box. Modern cards are priced by the player, the parallel, and the grade: rookies, autographs, and low-numbered cards of players people are chasing sell fast one at a time, and the rest moves best in groups.

The main options, side by side

• eBay, listed yourself. At eBay's standard rate, which its Starter store also pays, 13.25% of each sale up to $7,500 and 2.35% above that; with a Basic or higher eBay Store, 12.35% up to $2,500 and 2.35% above. Add $0.40 per order over $10, and note that eBay figures its fee on the total the buyer pays, including shipping and sales tax. Paid after the sale. Best for valuable singles, if you have an account and the time. The full breakdown is in what eBay really takes.
• PSA consignment. One fee to PSA that covers eBay's: 13% under $500 (plus $3 under $100), stepping down to 7% at $5,000 and up. Paid about a week after the buyer pays. Best for liquid PSA slabs that are already at PSA.
• PSA Offers. No selling fee, and payment starts when you accept. Only for PSA cards at grade reveal or in the PSA Vault, and only when a partner dealer wants the card.
• Auction house. Goldin, Heritage, and Fanatics Collect are the big names. The buyer pays a premium, commonly around 20%; seller terms vary, and Fanatics Collect currently charges no seller fee on graded cards in its Weekly and Premier auctions and adds a bonus to the hammer price. Paid in weeks to months. Best for trophy cards with deep demand and no deadline.
• Consignment service. A percentage of each sale, paid as each card sells, often over months. Best for high-value singles you want sold at market without doing the listing yourself.
• Other marketplaces. COMC, SportsCardsPro, and live-selling apps like Whatnot. Smaller audiences than eBay, each with its own fees and rules; worth a look once you know what eBay would leave you.
• Card show or local shop. No fee, because the dealer's costs are built into the offer. Paid on the spot. Best for quick cash in person, from a dealer who knows your kind of cards.
• Direct buyer, like us. No fee, because the buyer's costs are built into the offer. Paid once your cards arrive and are verified. Best for whole collections, groups of slabs, and valuable cards you want sold for one fixed number before they ship.

Facebook groups and forums can work for small sales between people who know each other's reputations, but they carry the most scam risk of any route. In a private sale to someone you cannot verify, get paid before you ship, and never accept "friends and family" payments for anything valuable.

What each route actually nets: three common situations

One raw card that sells for about $300

List it on eBay. After the fee and the $0.40 order fee you keep about $260 at eBay's standard rate, or about $263 with a Basic or higher store, before shipping and supplies. Because it sells for more than $200, the card goes through eBay's authentication check with PSA on its way to the buyer. A shop or a dealer will pay you less, because they face the same fee when they resell it. Unless you need the money today or want nothing to do with eBay, the marketplace wins this one.

One PSA 10 that sells for about $3,000

Now the fee tiers matter. Listing it yourself costs about $398 in eBay fees at the standard rate, or about $321 with a Basic or higher store, leaving roughly $2,602 or $2,679. PSA's consignment fee at that price is 9%, which leaves $2,730, and PSA does the listing, but the slab has to be at PSA first. A PSA Offer, if one appears, costs nothing to accept. A dealer's offer will usually come in below these nets on a card this liquid; what it buys you is one fixed number up front, with nothing to list and no auction to watch. If the slab is already at PSA and you can wait, PSA's own consignment is hard to beat. If it is in your safe, or it is one of several graded slabs you want sold together, get a direct offer too and compare. Our guide to where to sell PSA graded cards runs these numbers at other prices.

A 2,000-card collection with 25 cards that matter

With a big mixed collection, the answer changes. Listing 2,000 cards one at a time is weeks of work, and most of them would sell for less than the fee and postage. The practical choices are to sell the 25 good cards individually and the rest in lots, or to sell everything to one buyer. If you go with one buyer, make sure the 25 cards that matter were priced one by one, and ask for that list. A buyer who did the work can show it to you; our guide to what a fair collection offer looks like explains what to check.

A collection with key cards like these is what we are built for, whether it is your own or an inherited collection. Send photos of what you have and we will come back with an actual offer before you ship anything, with the key cards priced individually. Get your offer and compare it to what the listing route would leave you.

The costs that are not in any fee table

• Returns and claims. Marketplaces tend to side with buyers. A "not as described" return, a damage claim, or a package marked delivered that the buyer says never came can cost you the sale, and sometimes the card.
• Scams aimed at sellers. Fake payment notices, overpayment tricks, and buyers who want you to ship outside the platform. Most of them target new sellers.
• Payout holds. Newer accounts and larger sales can see funds held for days or weeks.
• Price movement while you wait. Every week a card sits unsold or waits for an auction slot is a week the market can move, in either direction.
• Your time. Photographing, describing, answering questions, and trips to the post office. Worth it on your best cards. Hard to justify on the rest.

None of this means you should avoid eBay. We have thousands of cards listed there ourselves. It means your real result is the sale price, minus the fees, minus these costs, and that is the number to hold any offer against. Dealers face the same costs, which is why their offers sit below the sales record. When you ship valuable cards anywhere, insure them, track them, and pack them properly.

Where a direct buyer fits, and where it does not

A direct buyer trades some of the price for certainty, speed, and far less work. That trade is worth it when:

• You are selling a whole collection or a stack of slabs and want it done in one transaction.
• Your cards are spread across grading companies, raw and graded, several sports.
• You want a fixed number before anything ships, instead of waiting on listings or an auction.
• You would rather not deal with buyers, returns, or claims.

For one liquid, high-value card you have the time to sell yourself, eBay or PSA will usually net more, and a trophy card with deep demand may do best at a major auction; get our offer on those only if you want one fixed number to compare. We do not consign cards and we do not do appraisals. We are buyers: we make an actual offer, and you decide.

With us, you send phone photos and get an actual offer before anything ships, usually within 48 hours. If you accept, your cards ship on our prepaid, insured label and are verified on camera when they arrive. If they match your submission, the accepted offer is what you are paid, once they are verified; if something is materially different, we contact you before any adjustment, and if you decline, your cards come back free and insured. How selling to us works has every step, and our Recent Intake wall shows what other collectors have sent. That is The Memphis Standard™: lock your offer before you ship.

Common questions

One Great Card, a Stack of Slabs, or a Collection?

Send phone photos and get an actual offer before anything ships, usually within 48 hours. Your cards travel on our prepaid, insured label, are verified on camera when they arrive, and come back free and insured if you decline. No obligation.

Get Your Offer Everything We Buy